Thanksgiving pies in Bolivar: local menus to plan from

If you're planning Thanksgiving pies in Bolivar, start with the whole-pie menu at Smith's Restaurant and the dessert list from Citizens Memorial Hospital's catering service. Both give you specific flavors to consider before you place an order.

These are regular menu choices, checked October 21, 2026. Confirm the flavor, price and pickup date for your Thanksgiving plans before paying.

A whole pecan pie in a foil pan beside an open bakery box.

A whole pecan pie ready to pack for dinner.

Whole pies at Smith's Restaurant

The Smith's whole-pie menu lists a price of $22.99. Flavor choices include pumpkin, pecan, chocolate, coconut, lemon meringue and peanut butter.

The restaurant is at 1340 State Highway U in Bolivar. Its menu directs customers to call 417-777-6484 to check availability or place a special order.

Choose the flavor before you settle the rest of dessert. If someone else is bringing pumpkin pie, a cream pie gives the table another choice. Ask how the pie should be stored if you'll collect it before the day of the meal.

Pie and pumpkin rolls through CMH catering

The CMH catering menu lists apple, pecan and pumpkin pies. It also includes cream pies, sugar-free apple and sugar-free cherry. Pumpkin rolls appear in its sweet selections.

CMH directs order questions to its catering manager at 417-328-7747, including price and availability for pickup, delivery or to-go orders.

Have your meal date and guest count ready. Ask how many people the chosen dessert serves, how much the full order costs, and when you can collect it. Treat those answers as part of the order, rather than assuming every pie or roll comes in the same size.

Choose Thanksgiving dessert by the meal you're joining

If you're bringing dessert to someone else's home, ask what is already on the menu. That helps you choose a second flavor or bring the amount the host needs.

For a larger meal, decide whether guests will want full slices or small tastes of several desserts. Ask the seller about serving size before deciding how many to buy.

A sugar-free label doesn't answer every food need. If a guest has an allergy, ask about the ingredients and how the dessert is made.

Settle these details when ordering

  • The exact dessert and flavor.
  • The quantity and number of servings.
  • The full price and payment terms.
  • The pickup date, time and address.
  • Storage and serving directions.

Write the pickup details beside the rest of your meal plans. If another person will collect the order, share the order name and confirmation with them.

For the table itself, our Thanksgiving table guide has ideas for leaving room for the food. For a smaller fall treat before the holiday, see the pumpkin dessert guide.

D.H. Henson

D.H. Henson writes local news and stories for Bolivar MO Life. His work covers schools, sports, community events and places in Bolivar, Missouri, and nearby Polk County.

https://www.bolivarmolife.com/dh-henson
Previous
Previous

The Ross sisters and their Bolivar photo studio

Next
Next

Bolivar Middle School food drive: dates and how to help